User:Song Xin

                                                                    Jianmen Pass

1. Geographic Location and Brief History

 Jianmen Pass, also known as Jiange Pass, is one of China's ten most famous mountain passes. It is located 12 kilometers southeast of Jiange County, Sichuan Province, in the middle section of the Dajian Mountains, a branch of the Longmen Mountains. Situated in a strategic valley between two mountains, it guards the vital route of the Golden Ox Road. Its unique terrain—"two towering cliffs forming a gate-like gap with a narrow path threading through"—earned it the name "Sword Gate" (Jianmen) and the longstanding reputation as "The First Strategic Pass Under Heaven."  
 During the Shu Han dynasty, Chancellor Zhuge Liang established Jianmen Pass as a defensive stronghold during his Northern Expeditions against Wei. The Tang Dynasty formally institutionalized it as both an administrative and military outpost under Jiange Prefecture. The Song Dynasty maintained its status, at times directly administering it under the capital and governing Jianmen County. The Yuan Dynasty abolished the pass in favor of a courier station, while the Ming Dynasty reinstated it. The Qing Dynasty again replaced it with a postal station, which remained operational until 1926.  
 Jianmen Pass's formidable terrain made it a critical artery for economic and cultural exchange between Central China and the Southwest, as well as a fiercely contested military stronghold. Unlike Shanhaiguan and Jiayuguan in the north—renowned for defending against nomadic invasions—Jianmen Pass not only held the military advantage of "being impregnable to assault" but also served as a vital trade and cultural corridor along the Shu Roads. Historically, Zhuge Liang fortified the pass during his campaigns, turning it into a key defensive barrier for Shu Han. By the Tang and Song dynasties, it had evolved into a commercial hub linking Central China and the Southwest. This dual identity—as both a military fortress and a trade thoroughfare—shaped Jianmen Pass's distinctive "Shu Roads-Three Kingdoms" cultural landscape within China's frontier fortress heritage.  

2. Major Cultural Landscapes Jiang Wei’s Tomb

 Located 1 km south of Jianmen Pass near the Boyu Temple, Jiang Wei’s Tomb is an earthen mound measuring 2.8 meters in length, 2 meters in width, and 1.5 meters in height. In front of the tomb stands a pavilion housing a stele inscribed with “Tomb of Jiang Wei, Great General of Han.” The pavilion features a couplet:  

“His ambition lay in the Central Plains, exhausting a lifetime of courage and wisdom; His spirit dwells at Jianmen, eternally shining as a hero for millennia.”

Jiang Wei (202–264), courtesy name Boyue, was born in Jixian, Tianshui (present-day Gangu, Gansu). Originally a Wei officer, he surrendered to Shu Han and gained Zhuge Liang’s trust, rising to become a prominent general in Shu’s later years. He held titles such as "Conquering West General", "Auxiliary Han General", "Guardian of the West General", "Governor of Liangzhou", and "Great General". During Wei’s invasion of Shu, he defended Jianmen Pass until Liu Shan’s surrender forced his capitulation to Wei’s Zhong Hui. In 264 (Xianxi 1), Jiang Wei feigned allegiance to Zhong Hui’s rebellion, plotting to restore Shu Han, but was killed when the plan failed. The tomb was erected at Jianmen Pass to honor his loyalty, symbolizing his eternal guardianship of the fortress. 

Little Jianmen Pass

 Situated over 10 km west of Jianmen Pass in Shuangqi Village, this site mirrors the main pass’s towering peaks, cliffs, and precipices, earning its nickname. Notable features include:  
  "Dadayao, Xiaodayao, Shuangqiya, Liangyiya, Foyeya, and Bingdiaoya"—each with legendary tales.  
  "Liangyiya (Clothes-Drying Cliff)": Folklore tells of a woodcutter who heard singing and glimpsed a fairy drying garments on the cliff. When he sang back, she vanished, leaving behind patterns on the rock.  
  "Bingdiaoya (Soldier Fortress Cliff)": A cave here sheltered anti-Qing rebels, who were later suffocated by Qing troops. Pre-1949, the cave held piles of bones. A damaged stele records: "“This fortress, named Bingdiaoya, served as a refuge in earlier dynasties… In spring of Jiaqing 5 (1800), rebel troops died here.”"  
  Nearby lies ""Kuzhu Fort"", built by Duan Yuanjian, a Southern Song commander, to resist the Yuan. The fort’s arched gateway retains inscriptions, including poems by Ming officials Li Bi and Gao Renzhong. Its perilous terrain and dramatic vistas heighten its historical allure.   

Pingxianghou Shrine

 Also called "Jiang Wei Shrine", "Boyue Temple", or "Jiang Gong Shrine", it was first built during the Ming Zhengde era (1506–1521). The original two-courtyard complex included:  
"Front Courtyard": Statues of Liu Bei, Guan Yu, and Zhang Fei ("Martial Sage Hall").  
""Rear Courtyard"": A seated statue of Jiang Wei ("Loyalty and Diligence Hall").  
 The current shrine, reconstructed in 2009 on the original site, preserves the historical layout with additions like the "Jiang Wei Hall", "Zhuge Liang’s Book-Giving Hall", and "Jiang Wei’s Tomb", forming an integrated tomb-shrine complex.  

3. Three Kingdoms Culture

 As a crucial military stronghold of the Shu-Han regime, Jianmen Pass is deeply intertwined with the strategic history of the Three Kingdoms period, particularly through the contributions of military strategists Zhuge Liang and Jiang Wei. According to *Records of the Three Kingdoms*, during Zhuge Liang’s Northern Expeditions against Cao Wei, he personally oversaw the fortification of Jianmen Pass, "building walls along the mountains and piling stones to form a pass," transforming the natural chasm into a systematic defensive structure. This established Jianmen Pass as the "Northern Key to Shu," reflecting Zhuge Liang’s military philosophy of "securing defenses by leveraging terrain" and his broader strategy of "using defense as a foundation for offense."  
 Jiang Wei, as the inheritor of Zhuge Liang’s military legacy, later centered Shu’s defensive system around Jianmen Pass. He repelled Wei forces eight times from this position, with *Chronicles of Huayang* recording his "holding Jianmen Pass to resist Zhong Hui," a classic example of defeating a larger army with fewer troops. The profound connection between these two Shu Han commanders and Jianmen Pass elevated it beyond a mere geographical feature, turning it into a cultural symbol of loyalty, courage, and strategic brilliance.  
 The Three Kingdoms cultural identity of Jianmen Pass manifests in three dimensions:  
 First, the pass’s architectural remains—such as preserved plank roads and beacon towers—serve as tangible heritage, showcasing Zhuge Liang’s principle of "adapting constructions to the terrain."  
 Second, local folklore, including tales like "Jiang Wei Defending Jianmen" and "Wooden Oxen and Gliding Horses Crossing the Pass," enriches oral traditions. Landmarks like the "General’s Platform" and "Jiang Wei’s Well" reflect popular reverence for Shu Han heroes.  

Third, the widespread influence of *Romance of the Three Kingdoms* since the Ming and Qing dynasties cemented literary narratives like "Jiang Wei’s Last Stand at Jianmen," reinforcing the pass’s image as Shu’s "spiritual bulwark." Notably, this cultural framing carries distinct values—Zhuge Liang is venerated as the "embodiment of wisdom," his defenses embodying Confucian foresight, while Jiang Wei is romanticized as a "tragic hero," his defiance symbolizing loyalty against impossible odds.

 From a cultural geography perspective, Jianmen Pass’s Three Kingdoms narrative exemplifies the transformation of "historical space → collective memory → cultural identity." Modern commemorations, such as the Zhuge Liang Temple, Jiang Wei statues, and annual Three Kingdoms festivals, demonstrate how military history has evolved into a core resource for regional identity. As Qing scholar Gu Zuyu noted in Essays on Geography and History: "Jianmen’s impregnability lies not only in its terrain but also in the enduring legacy of Zhuge Liang and Jiang Wei." This fusion of natural fortification and humanistic spirit encapsulates the profound allure of China’s historic passes.  

4.Shu Roads Culture

 As a pivotal site along the ancient Shu Roads, Jianmen Pass is deeply embedded in the historical evolution of these routes. Geographically, it occupies the most treacherous section of the Golden Ox Road, a vital corridor linking the Central Plains with the Sichuan Basin. Initially constructed during the Warring States period, this route became an official post road in the Han Dynasty and flourished during the Tang and Song eras as a key segment of the "Southern Silk Road." Jianmen Pass's strategic position thus solidified its role as a cultural cornerstone of Shu Roads heritage.  

Material Culture

 The surrounding area preserves well-maintained remnants of the ancient Shu Roads. The extant stone-paved pathways bear distinct hoof marks and wheel ruts, silent witnesses to centuries of bustling commercial activity. Particularly noteworthy are the remains of ‘Lanmaqiang’ (Horse-Barrier Walls) near Jianmen Pass—low stone walls built along precipitous sections. These structures, serving both protective and engineering purposes, exemplify the ingenuity of ancient craftsmen and their sophisticated understanding of mountain travel safety.  

Ecological Culture

 The nearby ‘Cuiyun Corridor’ (Emerald Cloud Corridor) stands as a model of ancient road greening. Stretching approximately five kilometers, this section of the old post road is flanked by over 8,000 ancient cypresses, many exceeding a millennium in age. Beyond their soil-stabilizing and windbreaking functions, these trees create a unique "emerald cloud" landscape, immortalized in Ming poet Yang Shen's verse: "The Emerald Cloud Corridor, veiled in azure mist." Inscriptions like"Guanyoubai" (Official-Owned Cypress) on some trees attest to the institutionalized management of road greening in imperial China.  

Spiritual Culture

 The Shu Roads culture at Jianmen Pass embodies profound humanistic values. Generations of literati traversing this route left enduring literary legacies. Li Bai's "The Shu Roads' hardship surpasses climbing to heaven" and Du Fu's "Heaven wrought this peril; Jianmen's might dominates the world" capture the pass's sublime grandeur. These works not only enriched Shu Roads culture but also elevated Jianmen Pass's cultural significance.    
 Jianmen Pass's Shu Roads heritage offers a lens through which to examine China's ancient transportation civilization. This cultural legacy—integrating military defense, commercial exchange, and ecological preservation—holds immense historical value while offering insights for modern ecological development. As the Qing-era Jiange County Annals observed: "The Shu Roads' challenge lies not in towering mountains or deep waters, but in the harmony between human endeavor and nature's craftsmanship." This spirit of "unity between heaven and humanity" epitomizes the essence of Chinese civilization.  

5.Poetic Culture

 As a quintessential representation of ancient Chinese military fortresses and geographical barriers, the precipitous terrain of Jianmen Pass has transcended its physical form in literary works across dynasties, evolving into a cultural symbol embodying the spatial consciousness and spiritual ideals of the Chinese nation.  
 From Zhang Zai's Inscription on Jianmen(Jin Dynasty), which established its aesthetic tone as "the extremity of earthly peril, the zenith of rugged paths," to Li Bai's *The Difficulty of the Shu Roads(Tang Dynasty), which imbued it with heroic grandeur—"Jianmen's towering cliffs stand formidable; one man could hold the pass against ten thousand"—and Du Fu's Jianmen, which interpreted its majesty through cosmic resonance—"Only Heaven could forge such peril; Jianmen's might dominates the world"—these canonical texts collectively constructed Jianmen Pass's dual cultural imagery: "natural peril versus human valor."
 The visual impact of the pass is further intensified through multidimensional spatial narratives:  

- Viewed from outside the pass, its stone walls resemble iron-blooded battlements; - Seen from the side, its peaks stand like loyal sentinels; - Gazed upon from afar, its ridges surge like ten thousand galloping steeds.

 This transformation of static geological wonders into dynamic wartime imagery profoundly reflects the Chinese tradition of "using landscapes to convey ideals" and the philosophical belief that "adversity breeds heroes."  
 The cultural imagery of Jianmen Pass is, in essence, a condensed chronicle of China's spiritual geography. Its accumulated literary depictions not only completed the symbolic process of natural landscapes but also mirrored ancient literati's dialectical contemplation of "peril versus courage" and "divine craftsmanship versus human endeavor." This narrative paradigm—transforming geographical severity into cultural power—exemplifies the unique wisdom of Chinese civilization in "transforming heaven and earth into literature," offering a quintessential case study for understanding the interplay between traditional Chinese landscape aesthetics and humanistic spirit.  

Terms and Expressions 1.Jianmen Pass  剑门关 2.Ancient Shu Road 古蜀道 3.Golden Ox Road 金牛道 4.Three Kingdoms Culture 三国文化 5.Cuiyun Corridor 翠云廊 6.The First Strategic Pass Under Heaven 天下第一雄关 7.Military Fortress 军事要塞 8.Shu-Han regime 蜀汉政权 9.Zhuge Liang 诸葛亮 10.Jiang Wei 姜维

Questions 1.What are the cultural and historical figures of the Three Kingdoms directly related to Jiange Pass? 2.What are the famous historical events related to the Three Kingdoms culture directly related to the Sword Gate Pass? 3.Which is the ancient Shu Road where Jianmen Pass is located? 4. How does Li Bai's "The Difficulty of the Shu Road" reflect the culture of the Shu Road at Jiange Pass? 5. Jianmen Pass is often regarded as a symbol of "loyalty" and "tragic heroism" in the stories of the Three Kingdoms (such as Jiang Wei's death at Jianmen Pass). How does this collective memory shape the unique Chinese folk aesthetic of "failed heroes"? Compare the heroic narratives in Western culture (such as Greek tragedies) to analyze the Chinese ethical concepts behind the differences. 6.The ancient Shu Road (such as Jianmen Pass) was not only a geographical passage, but also a "cultural boundary" for the central dynasty to control the southwest. How to understand the political and cultural functions of the Shu Road in the "Huaxia-marginal" order from the concept of "Nine Provinces" in the Tribute of Yu to the "reform of native chieftainship" in the Qing Dynasty?

                                                                     剑门关
1.地理位置和简要来历
   剑门关，又名剑阁关，中国十大名关之一，位于四川省剑阁县县城东南12公里、龙门山支脉——大剑山中段，为两山之间的峡谷隘口，扼守金牛古道要冲。因“两山对峙如门，一径中通似线”的独特地形，故曰“剑门”，自古享有“天下第一雄关”的美誉。
   蜀汉丞相诸葛亮伐魏，于此始建剑门关，设官戍守；唐代置剑门关，作为行政军事建制隶于剑州，宋代仍置剑门关，一度直隶京师，辖剑门县；元代废官置驿，明代复置关，清代废关置驿，至民国15年（1926年）以前仍设驿站。
   剑门关，地势险要，是沟通中原和西南经济、文化的动脉，亦为兵家必争之地。与以前北方以防御游牧民族著称的山海关、嘉峪关不同，剑门关不仅有“一夫当关，万夫莫开”的军事价值，更因地处蜀道而承载着丰富的商贸文化交流功能。历史上，诸葛亮北伐时曾在此修筑关城，使其成为蜀汉政权的重要屏障；唐宋时期，这里又成为连接中原与西南的商贸枢纽。这种兼具军事防御与商贸通衢的双重属性，使剑门关在中国关隘文化中形成了独特的“蜀道——三国”文化景观。

2.主要人文景观
   姜维墓，位于剑门关以南1公里处的钵盂寺旁。姜维墓系一土冢，墓长2.8米，宽2米，高1.5米。墓前有一停堂，堂之正中有墓碑，上刻“汉大将军姜维之墓”。亭堂两侧有对联一副，文日:“志在中原费尽平生胆智；神栖剑阁永昭千代英灵”。姜维（202~264年），字伯约，天水冀县（今甘肃甘谷）人。本为魏人，迫降蜀汉后得诸葛亮赏识，为蜀汉后期的名将。历任蜀汉征西将军、辅汉将军、镇西将军、凉州刺史、大将军等。魏军攻蜀，他坚守剑阁，刘禅出降，始被迫降于魏将钟会。“咸熙元年（264年）钟会叛魏，维伪与结盟，拟乘机恢复蜀汉，不幸事败被杀。”为了纪念他对蜀国的功绩，后人在剑门关的关口为姜维修建了一座墓，表示姜维仍然在镇守着剑门关。
   小剑门关，，位于剑门关隘以西10余公里的双旗村，奇峰、峭壁、悬崖、山势酷似剑门关，实为险峻。人称“小剑门关”。大吊崖、小吊崖、双旗崖、晾衣崖、佛爷崖、兵碉崖等景致引人入胜。而每一处景致，都有优美、悲壮动人的传说。晾衣崖传说是，一樵夫早出砍柴，隐隐听见歌声，他循声来到崖前，见云端有一美女在崖边边唱歌、边晾衣裙。樵夫情不自禁地也唱起情歌，美女闻之，羞而飘逝，留下的仙衣化成崖壁上的图案。在大吊岩峭壁间有一崖洞，可容数百人，称兵碉崖。为反清义军战败避居于此，被清兵烧熏，窒死洞内。解放前洞内白骨累累。尚存残碑记载：“是碉也，名兵碉崖，系先朝避兵之处⋯⋯大清嘉庆五年春，贼兵战死。”附近有宋末隆庆府守将段元鉴为抗元修筑的苦竹寨，寨门口石卷洞遗刻尚存，并刻有明代李壁、高任重二刺史的题诗和词。此寨处绝险之地，景色奇险。
   平襄侯祠，又称姜维祠、伯约庙、姜公祠、钵盂寺。始建于明正德年间，分前后两院，前院塑刘关张坐像，名武圣宫，后院正殿塑姜维坐像，名忠勤祠。现在看到的姜维祠是2009年在原址上重建的，重建的姜维祠基本保持了原有的建筑风貌，包括姜维殿、孔明授书殿和姜维墓，属于墓祠。

3.三国文化
   剑门关作为蜀汉政权的重要军事屏障，其文化内涵与三国时期的战略历史密不可分，尤以诸葛亮与姜维两位军事家的经营最具代表性。据《三国志》记载，诸葛亮北伐曹魏时，曾亲临剑门，“因山筑城，垒石为关”，将天然险隘改造为系统化防御工事，奠定了剑门关作为“蜀北锁钥”的战略地位。诸葛亮对剑门关的营建，不仅体现其"依险固守"的军事思想，更蕴含"以守为攻"的北伐战略智慧。而姜维作为诸葛亮军事路线的继承者，在蜀汉后期以剑门关为核心构建防御体系，先后八次依托此关阻挡魏军南下，《华阳国志》载其"据剑阁以拒钟会"，创造了以少胜多的经典战例。这两位蜀汉军事统帅与剑门关的深厚渊源，使该关隘超越了单纯的地理存在，成为忠勇智谋的文化象征。
   剑门关的三国文化特质主要体现在三个维度：其一，关隘建筑本身作为实体文化遗产，至今保留的栈道、烽燧等遗迹，仍可窥见诸葛亮“因地制宜”的筑城理念；其二，民间流传的“姜维守剑阁”“木马流马过雄关”等传说，形成了丰富的口头传统，如当地“点将台”“姜维井”等风物命名，均折射出民众对蜀汉英雄的历史记忆；其三，明清以来《三国演义》的广泛传播，使“姜维死守剑门”的文学叙事深入人心，进一步强化了剑门关作为“蜀汉精神堡垒”的符号意义。值得注意的是，这种文化建构 存在明显的价值取向——诸葛亮被视为“智慧化身”，其剑门布防体现“未雨绸缪”的儒家治国理念；而姜维则被塑造为“悲情英雄”，其死守孤关的行为被赋予“知其不可而为之”的忠义内涵。
   从文化地理学视角看，剑门关的三国叙事实际上完成了“历史空间—集体记忆—文化认同”的转化过程。当代关城内的武侯祠、姜维塑像等纪念物，以及每年举行的三国文化节，均表明这种始于军事的历史记忆，已演变为地方文化认同的核心资源。正如清代学者顾祖禹在《读史方舆纪要》中所言：“剑阁之险，非地势使然，亦诸葛、姜维之遗烈也。”这种将自然险要与人文精神相融合的文化逻辑，正是中国历史名关独特魅力的深层根源。

4.蜀道文化
   剑门关作为古蜀道上的重要节点，其文化内涵与蜀道的历史发展密不可分。从地理空间来看，剑门关位于古蜀道之一金牛道最险要的段落，是连接中原与巴蜀的咽喉要地。这条始建于战国时期的古道，在汉代成为官方驿道，至唐宋时期达到鼎盛，成为“南丝绸之路”的重要组成部分。剑门关的特殊地理位置，使其成为蜀道文化的重要载体。
   在物质文化层面，剑门关周边的古蜀道遗迹保存完好。现存的石板路面上，清晰可见深浅不一的马蹄印和车辙痕迹，这些印记见证了千百年来商旅往来的繁荣景象。特别值得一提的是，剑门关附近的拦马墙遗址，这种建于险段外侧的石砌矮墙，既具有防护功能，又体现了古代工匠的智慧。其独特的建造工艺，反映了古人对山地交通安全的深刻认识。
   在生态文化方面，剑门关所在的翠云廊堪称古代道路绿化的典范。这段长约十里的古驿道两侧，现存8000余株古柏，其中不少树龄超过千年。这些古柏不仅具有防风固土的功能，更形成了独特的“翠云”景观。明代诗人杨慎“翠云廊，苍烟护”的诗句，生动描绘了这一奇观。值得注意的是，古柏上保留的“官油柏”等铭牌，证实了古代官方对道路绿化管理的制度化。
   在精神文化层面，剑门关蜀道文化蕴含着丰富的人文内涵。历代文人墨客途径此地，留下了大量诗词歌赋。李白的“蜀道难，难于上青天”成为千古绝唱，杜甫的“惟天有设险，剑门天下壮”则展现了雄关的壮美。这些文学作品不仅丰富了蜀道文化的内涵，更提升了剑门关的文化品位。
   剑门关蜀道文化的当代价值在于，它为我们提供了一个理解中国古代交通文明的窗口。这种将军事防御、商贸流通、生态保护融为一体的文化遗产，不仅具有重要的历史研究价值，对当代的生态文明建设也具有启示意义。正如清代《剑州志》所言：蜀道之难，不在山高水深，而在人力与天工之相济。”这种“天人合一”的蜀道精神，正是中华文明的精髓所在。
5.诗词文化
   作为中国古代军事要塞与地理屏障的典范，剑门关的险峻地势在历代文人的书写中逐渐超越其物理属性，升华为承载华夏民族空间认知与精神象征的文化符号。从晋代张载《剑阁铭》以"穷地之险，极路之峻"奠定其地理极险的审美基调，到唐代李白《蜀道难》以"剑阁峥嵘而崔嵬，一夫当关，万夫莫开"赋予其英雄主义气概，再到杜甫《剑门》诗中"惟天有设险，剑门天下壮"的天人感应式诠释，这些经典文本共同构建了剑门关"天险—人勇"的双重文化意象。其视觉震撼更通过多维度空间叙事得以强化：关外回望时的石壁如铁血城墙，侧观时群峰似忠勇卫戍，远眺处山势若万马奔腾——这种由静态地质奇观向动态战争图景的意象转化，深刻体现了中国传统文化中"以山水喻志"的比德传统，以及"险阻生英杰"的哲学认知。
   剑门关的文化意象史，实为一部浓缩的中国精神地理志。其层累的文学书写不仅完成了自然景观的符号化进程，更折射出古代文人对于"险"与"勇"、"天工"与"人力"的辩证思考。这种将地理险峻转化为文化力量的叙事范式，正是中华文明"化天地为文章"的独特智慧体现，为理解中国传统山水审美与人文精神互动提供了典型样本。

术语和表达

1.Jianmen Pass  剑门关 2.Ancient Shu Road 古蜀道 3.Golden Ox Road 金牛道 4.Three Kingdoms Culture 三国文化 5.Cuiyun Corridor 翠云廊 6.The First Strategic Pass Under Heaven 天下第一雄关 7.Military Fortress 军事要塞 8.Shu-Han regime 蜀汉政权 9.Zhuge Liang 诸葛亮 10.Jiang Wei 姜维

问题

1.与剑门关直接相关的三国文化历史人物有哪些？ 2.与剑门关直接相关的三国文化有哪些著名的历史事迹？ 3.剑门关所在的古蜀道是哪一条？ 4.李白的《蜀道难》一文中怎样体现剑门关的蜀道文化？ 5.剑门关在三国故事中常被视为“忠诚”与“悲壮”的象征（如姜维死守剑门），这种集体记忆如何塑造了中国民间对“失败英雄”的独特审美？试对比西方文化中的英雄叙事（如希腊悲剧），分析其差异背后的中国伦理观念。 6.古代蜀道（如剑门关）不仅是地理通道，更是中央王朝控制西南的“文化边界”。从《禹贡》“九州”观念到清代“改土归流”，如何理解蜀道在“华夏-边缘”秩序中的政治文化功能？

参考文献

[1]付玏. 蜀道文化场景绘画创作元素调查研究——以剑门关周边为例[J]. 中外文化交流, 2025(1). [2]何国辉. 剑门关诗文中的文化立场问题[J]. 中华文化论坛, 2015(9). [3]胡玉平. 唐宋剑门诗文化研究[D]. 重庆: 西南大学, 2011. [4]涂然. 蜀道文化多重价值分析——以广元段为例[J]. 今日中国论坛, 2013(7). [5]王旭辉. 剑门关古镇保护与更新研究[D]. 绵阳: 西南科技大学, 2015. [6]韦跃龙. 四川剑门关地质公园旅游产品开发与可持续发展[D]. 成都: 成都理工大学, 2006.